Red Dead Redemption 2 is proof that Rockstar Games doesn’t cut corners when building a living, breathing world. Even as the game approaches its seventh year, players continue to stumble upon tiny, heartfelt details that keep the experience fresh.
One such discovery recently caught the attention of fans on Reddit. A player shared a video from their seventh playthrough—yes, seventh—where Arthur Morgan is heard softly singing to himself while riding through the mountains. The post simply read: “Seventh playthrough and I’ve never heard him sing this song.”
It turns out, many longtime players were just as surprised. One top commenter replied, “Third playthrough… Never heard him sing. Crazy game.” Another chimed in with over 2,000 hours logged and still hadn’t come across this small musical moment.
So, how do you trigger this hidden gem? Redditor The_Calarg offered some advice. According to them, the key is to slow down. “Get out into the hills—not the snowy areas—and take your time,” they wrote. “Arthur won’t sing if you’re galloping or sprinting. A slow trot or walking pace is best.”
They also mentioned that Arthur is more likely to sing during peaceful stretches of travel, particularly when leaving places like Clemens Point or while rowing a boat from Saint Denis to Annesburg. However, if he interacts with anyone or performs any other actions, like shooting or talking, it seems to reset the singing timer.
This kind of attention to detail is exactly why Red Dead Redemption 2 continues to impress years after release. Rockstar didn’t just build a game; they built a world meant to be savored.
So next time you saddle up, don’t rush. Slow it down, take in the scenery—and you might just catch Arthur humming a tune you’ve never heard before.
